logo

57 pages 1 hour read

Timothy Garton Ash

The Magic Lantern

Timothy Garton AshNonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 1990

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Background

Ideological Context: Communism and Liberalism in Europe’s 20th Century

With the growth of an organized workers’ movement in the mid-19th century influenced by the ideology of Karl Marx, communist and socialist parties increasingly competed for influence and political power in last decades of the Russian Empire. Russia’s October Revolution of 1917 saw the tsarist state fall to an explicitly socialist regime led by Lenin’s Bolshevik Party. Where Marx insisted that the revolution to overthrow socialism would be led by the workers, i.e., the proletariat, Lenin believed that a vanguard party could lead a state to revolution and establish a dictatorship of the proletariat. Lenin’s successors, particularly Stalin, insisted that socialism could exist only in the Soviet Union, and a global revolution could come later.

Marxism-Leninism in practice consisted of one-party rule by a worker’s party, state control of the economy and mass media, and strict surveillance of the population to prevent the establishment of a coherent opposition, often through use of a secret police force. The commitment to social equality in communist regimes meant guaranteed housing, education, and employment, and some commitment to gender equality and maternity leave. These social commitments were meant to demonstrate not only progress toward a communist utopia, but also indicate superiority to capitalist regimes that lacked such guarantees. As anthropologist Katherine Verdery notes, socialist economies often concentrated on heavy industry that allowed the state to control and distribute resources and struggled to expand into consumer goods, which was a routine source of popular discontent.

Liberalism, broadly understood to mean a commitment to the rule of law, a free market economy with minimal state interference, and a free press with free elections, gained increasing traction in the 19th century as well, particularly in Britain, France, and Germany. The victory of liberal democracies over Hitler’s Third Reich in 1945 had significant influence on social policy and domestic politics. Politicians contended with increasing calls for welfare states, including pension plans and state subsidized health care, in recognition of their obligations to citizens who had defeated fascism. Liberalism encompassed both conservative parties, who supported smaller welfare states, and social democratic parties, which supported their expansion, as both were opposed to communism and critical of the Soviet Union. Garton Ash, as a critic of both communism and the conservative government of Margaret Thatcher, is thus entirely representative of European liberal politics.

Historical Context: World War II and the Cold War

In Europe, World War II was both an ideological and a geopolitical contest between the Axis Powers—Hitler’s fascist Third Reich, Italy, Japan, and eventually countries from Eastern Europe—and the Allied Powers, a temporary alliance between the liberal democracies of Britain, France, the UK, and the socialist Soviet Union. After 1945, the Allied alliance became fraught with tension as the Soviet Union held military primacy in Eastern Europe, and its leadership under Stalin was distrustful of capitalist powers and anxious about future security. By 1946, British Prime Minister Winston Churchill spoke of an “iron curtain” dividing Western Europe’s democracies from the Soviet-allied states of Eastern Europe. Within Eastern Europe, new Soviet-aligned governments, often with Communists as one coalition partner among many, began to expand free access to education and promote economic transformation and social leveling, which earned them some domestic support. The division of Germany by the Allied Powers in 1945 became a particularly important point of tension as Stalin was opposed to any attempt to rebuild a strong Germany. All the newly formed states of Eastern Europe rejected Marshall Plan aid from the United States. In 1948, the Soviets briefly attempted to block free entry and exit of goods and individuals through Berlin in what became known as the Berlin Blockade, with the Allies countering with an airlift of food and supplies.

The decades of Cold War that followed were fought ideologically and militarily, but outside Europe, as the prospect of nuclear war between the Soviet Union and the United States made open conflict too risky. The Soviet Union established the Warsaw Pact as a counterweight to the United States and Western European democracies forming the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO). By 1947-1948, communist and workers’ parties increasingly consolidated one-party rule, including in Czechoslovakia, Hungary, and Poland. Stalin’s death in 1953 sparked a period of liberalization and hopes for economic and social reform, known as de-Stalinization. But these reforms took place without any real rejection of Marxist-Leninist ideology, and the Cold War’s global divisions of the world between socialist states and capitalist ones remained intact.

Reform within socialist systems began in earnest when Stalin’s successor, Nikita Khrushchev, denounced Stalin’s “cult of personality” in the spring of 1956. It was in this atmosphere that Hungarian students protested en masse until Imre Nagy’s government attempted to leave the Warsaw Pact that autumn. This uprising was crushed by Soviet troops, signaling that reform would only be tolerated on a limited basis. The Prague Spring of 1968, sparked by the appointment of reformer Alexander Dubček and his calls for “socialism with a human face” established that all uprisings considered to be anti-Soviet would be put down by force what became known as the Brezhnev Doctrine.

In the 1970s and 1980s, dissident movements grew throughout the region, and within the Soviet Union. These were partly inspired by the signing of the Helsinki Accords, which obligated signatories to commit to safeguarding human rights. 1989 marked a historical turning point, signaling a kind of conclusion to the Cold War, as Mikhail Gorbachev rejected interventionist foreign policy while pursuing domestic reform and open political debate within the Soviet Union itself.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 57 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools