logo

48 pages 1 hour read

Camille DeAngelis

Bones & All

Camille DeAngelisFiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2015

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 4-6Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 4 Summary

Maren thinks about Sully during the two-day journey to St. Louis. She only has $15 and thinks that maybe she should have stayed with him. A woman named Samantha picks her up as she hitchhikes during the last stage of the trip. Maren gives her $5 for gas, but Samantha leaves her in a Walmart parking lot when Maren asks to stop to use the bathroom. She wonders if Samantha smelled something wrong with her, like the other girls in school.

In the store’s candy aisle, she sees a drunk man dressed in underwear, a cowboy hat, and boots. He talks to himself and threatens other customers. A young man in a green jersey, who looks slightly older than Maren, tells him to stop. The drunk man argues, and the man in the jersey invites him to step outside. Maren decides to save money by shoplifting a sandwich and a can of chickpeas. Outside, a worker named Andy asks if she has a can opener for the chickpeas. Once Maren realizes he isn’t going to turn her in, she agrees to meet him in the electronics section at nine o’clock. The TVs show a clip of Bill Clinton denying his sexual relations with Monica Lewinski. The boy in the green jersey appears next to her and says that lying on TV is in another league. She notices that he’s wearing a Stetson cowboy hat as she leaves with Andy.

Maren and Andy sit in his car, where she sees a book called The Master and Margarita. She opens to a passage that says, “Everything will turn out right, the world is built on that” (103). As they talk about their favorite books, Andy tries to hold her hand and she says no. He shows her a slash on his ribs, which he says is from his drunk father. Andy says his life sucks and that he thought she could understand. As he pressures her and pities himself, she begs him to stop being so nice. When he won’t stop making advances, she eats him.

Maren walks to the highway and decides to let a truck hit her. At the last moment, the boy in green pulls her back when she steps in front of a truck. Maren falls hard. The boy, whose name is Lee, explains that he got the hat and the keys to a truck from the drunk cowboy. He confesses that he saw what she did to Andy, and he says he won’t tell. He also discloses that he ate the cowboy.

They gather Andy’s clothes and book, and Lee says he also takes things, like her. They find the cowboy’s name—Barry—and address in his truck and head toward Barry’s home in Iowa. Maren tells Lee that she’s now met two people like her in a week. However, she has had suspicions of other people in the past. She thinks of her history teacher, Miss Anderson. Maren thought she had smelled the “old-penny smell” (112) on her, along with mouthwash. People hadn’t liked Miss Anderson, but they hadn’t avoided her like they do Maren. She realizes that not all eaters are the same.

Chapter 5 Summary

Maren washes her face at Barry’s house and hates that Lee has seen her like this, even though he has done the same thing. After she showers, she wonders if anyone besides Andy will think she’s pretty again.

Maren adds Andy’s name to her journal, and then she and Lee lay on a waterbed together. He says his first kill was also a babysitter. In the morning, someone knocks on the door and shouts for Barry. They don’t answer, but Maren can see that the woman has a child in the car. The woman slashes one of Barry’s tires and then leaves.

Lee quickly changes the tire and tells Maren that he wants her to come to Virginia with him so that they can look out for each other. He’s going there to give his sister, Kayla, driving lessons. Maren tells him about her grandparents, her mother, and Mrs. Harmon. Lee is surprised that Andy was the first time she has ever killed in a car because most people assume something different when they see steam on a car’s windows. Maren realizes that an eavesdropper might think they were talking about sex.

Lee is skeptical when Maren says Sully claimed only to eat the dead. They stop to get a new tire in Illinois. While Maren cleans the cab, Lee takes plywood from a dumpster and puts it in the back of the truck to protect them from the cold while they sleep outdoors. He also has the mechanic change the license plates.

At a state park, they lie in the back of the truck. Maren tells Lee about Samantha, and he says he doesn’t like people who break their word. Then he asks if her mother was afraid of her. When Maren doesn’t answer, Lee apologizes. She worries that her mother never loved her. The next day, they reach his recently deceased great-aunt’s abandoned house in Tingley, Virginia. Lee asks to see Maren’s journal. She lets him look at the pictures that she has taped in it, which include renderings of a famous cannibal named Sawyer Beane. In the pictures, he and a group of cannibals are eating in a cave around a fire. Maren thinks it looks cozy.

Lee wonders if Goya, the painter of Saturn Devouring His Son, was an eater. While she sleeps, Maren dreams about words dripping down a wall. She knows that her father painted the words, but she can’t read them.

Chapter 6 Summary

In the morning, Maren finds a note that says Lee went to give Kayla driving lessons. She tries to knit and watches TV. Soon, Lee brings her breakfast. Then he notices that Kayla has followed him on her bike. Maren listens to them argue on the porch. Kayla is worried about him, and Lee tells her to go back to school. Eventually, she leaves. She sees Maren through the window before she goes.

On the drive to Minnesota to find her father, Maren asks for driving lessons. While they camp that night, Lee asks to see what’s in her backpack. It’s mostly books: Some are hers, and some belonged to the people she has eaten. He asks about Kevin, who owned The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy. They discuss other people and other mementos that they took from them.

Lee says that Kayla knows something is different about him. He says he ate his babysitter because she abused him. Worse, his mom knew and didn’t stop it. Instead, she apologized and claimed there was no one else to watch him. He says the rush of eating someone makes him feel like a superhero, which makes Maren jealous. Lee doesn’t believe her. He says she likes it as much as he does.

Lee says that his mother dated bad guys who abused him, and he hated her for it. When he asks Maren about her mother, she describes her cooking, her love for classic movies, and the way she colored her hair.

She drives for an hour during the trip. One evening, they hear a preacher giving a live sermon to a congregation. He talks about everyone being brothers and sisters and insists that people must forgive themselves before they can forgive others. Lee is skeptical of Reverend Figtree’s message and says he once took Kayla to a similar event. The worshippers had booed her out of the room when she said she wasn’t sure if she believed in God.

When Lee tries to change the station, Maren insists that they keep listening and wants to attend a meeting the church is holding the next night. Lee then says he’ll take Maren to the meeting if she’ll tell the preacher exactly what she is. That ends the conversation. That night, Maren dreams of being in a church. Again, there are unrecognizable words written on the wall. People sing hymns in an unfamiliar language. Finally, the reverend tells her to kneel for forgiveness, and he looks menacing. 

Chapters 4-6 Analysis

Chapters 4-6 introduce Maren and Lee as a duo, beginning the start of a potential friendship, romance, and pairing of mutual protectiveness. Large sections of these chapters could fit neatly into typical road trip novel about first loves, if the first loves were not cannibals. Regardless, there are moments of genuine lightness in the interactions between Maren and Lee that highlight The Need for Connection and Understanding. Isolation, alienation, secrets, and shame are burdens. Lee offers Maren relief, if only temporarily, from all of these.

First, DeAngelis uses Andy to advance the theme of connection and highlight Maren’s loneliness. She wants Andy to act differently than other boys, but he doesn’t. When she resists his advances and asks him to stop, he tries to pressure her through self-pity, describing his loneliness as if it binds them together. Instead, Maren thinks, “Everyone is lonely, you can’t do something just because you’re lonely” (107). She eats him, treating him like she has treated other boys who wouldn’t take no for an answer. Andy’s death makes it possible for Lee to approach Maren and leads to him saving her life, just at the moment when she can no longer bear to live.

The novel The Master and Margarita is the other significant feature of the scene with Andy. It is a Russian novel whose main message is that good and evil require each other in order to exist: There is no good without evil, and vice versa. This challenges assumptions about morality, because it suggests that there is no way to banish evil from the world without sacrificing the good as well. Importantly, The Master and Margarita is, in part, a satire about Christian hypocrisy, which meshes with Lee’s cynical views on the sermon that they hear on the radio. When he challenges Maren to consider telling Reverend Figtree about her nature, it is a reminder about Identity and Self-Acceptance. Maren has yet to accept herself or her identity, so she cannot tell anyone else about her true nature: even someone who preaches about acceptance and forgiveness.

Lee’s entry into the narrative serves to teach Maren that there are other eaters besides herself and Sully and that she shouldn’t assume that they’re all the same. Lee’s history is as tragic as Maren’s; they discover that they both killed a babysitter as their first act of cannibalism. They discuss their first kills the way that others might talk about their first sexual encounters. Their appetites for flesh overwhelm them in the same way that lust sweeps people away, often with serious consequences.

Maren finds more peace with Lee than she ever thought possible, because he makes it possible for her to talk about the truth without qualifications. There is nothing she can say that will shock him. At the same time, his questions unsettle her because they make her reflect on her nature and identity, rather than their shared cessation of loneliness. When he asks her whether her mother was afraid of her, it reminds her that she hates the truth: “The truth is like the waiting jaws of a monster, a more menacing monster than I’ll ever be. It yawns beneath your feet, and you can’t escape it, and as soon as you drop, it chews you to pieces” (130). Nonetheless, even when Lee disagrees with her, she knows that he hears her: “Lee didn’t comment, but I could tell he was listening to me—really listening. No matter what he called himself, I knew he was my friend” (122). She calls him her friend, but he is also a mentor figure. Significantly, he does not mentor her in the ways of cannibalism, as was the case with Sully. Instead, he teaches her to drive, a duty that would typically fall to a parent.

The increasing dreams of her father in these chapters foreshadow Maren’s eventual encounter with him at Bridewell Hospital. The unfamiliar language on the walls of her dreams also raises the tension in the narrative because Maren can’t even speculate about their meaning. Finally, Lee’s apparent skepticism regarding some of Sully’s claims will prove to be prescient, as Sully will soon reenter Maren’s life.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 48 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools